| Platinum | MamaCass Cheesecakes |
| Gold | Jeannette's Custom Cakes |
| Silver | Elliott's Ice Cream |
| Bronze | Thyne's Family Bakery |
| Top Pick | Cake Superior |
| Top Pick | Inside The Box Café & Bakery |
| Top Pick | Rome's Your Independent Grocer |
| Top Pick | Roxy's Fry Shack |
| Top Pick | Scott Coffee Co. |
| Top Pick | The Cake Lady |