| Platinum | Big Arrow Takeout |
| Gold | The Stockhouse Grill |
| Silver | Roxy's Fry Shack |
| Bronze | Westside Cafe |
| Top Pick | Granny's Fish N' Chips |
| Top Pick | Heyden Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Jiggs & Reels Catering Co. |
| Top Pick | New York Fries |
| Top Pick | Out to Munch |
| Top Pick | Sandro's Family Restaurant |