| Platinum | Rome's Your Independent Grocer |
| Gold | Paesano Foods |
| Silver | Joe's No Frills |
| Silver | Metro |
| Silver | Pino's Get Fresh Foods |
| Bronze | City Meat Market |
| Bronze | Food Basics |
| Top Pick | Mill Market |
| Top Pick | Neal's Country Farm & Market |
| Top Pick | Sunnynook Farms |