| Platinum | Paesano Foods |
| Gold | City Meat Market |
| Silver | The Soup Witch |
| Bronze | Superior Home Bakery |
| Top Pick | Croatian Corner |
| Top Pick | Elliott's Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Q Cafe & Bakery |
| Top Pick | RJ's Market |
| Top Pick | Rome's Your Independent Grocer |
| Top Pick | Subway |