| Platinum | Mrs B's Pizza |
| Gold | Aurora's Westside |
| Silver | Aurora's Hillside |
| Silver | Perfecto Pizza - Sportscenter Bar & Grill |
| Bronze | Fratelli's Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Deluca's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Gino's Fired Up Kitchen & Bar |
| Top Pick | Gus's Pizza & Grill |
| Top Pick | Primo Pizza & Wings |
| Top Pick | Sandro's Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Boiler Room |
| Top Pick | Uncle Gino's Pizzeria |