| Platinum | Quattro Hotel & Conf. Centre |
| Gold | Algoma's Water Tower Inn & Suites |
| Silver | The Voyageur's Lodge and Cookhouse |
| Bronze | Delta Hotels by Marriott |
| Top Pick | Algoma Cabins & Motel |
| Top Pick | Ambassador Motel |
| Top Pick | Days Inn and Suites |
| Top Pick | Holiday Inn Express Sault Ste Marie |
| Top Pick | Sleep Inn |