| Platinum | Nonni's a Little Bit of This a Little Bit of That |
| Gold | Constance's Closet |
| Silver | Vincent Place Thrift Store |
| Bronze | The Ole' Warehouse |
| Top Pick | Four Cozy Corners Vintage and Artisan Shop |
| Top Pick | Habitat For Humanity |
| Top Pick | Stephanie's Joy |
| Top Pick | The Dragon Fly Shop |